UK UPA Client Panel demands User-Centred Services

People and their ability to communicate are the most important factors in choosing an agency to work with on usability studies suggested the four panellists at the UK UPA session on "What clients want from usability professionals".

Coming as a surprise to many, who believed financial arguments and expertise would figure higher in clients' expectations of a good team, the panellists clearly favoured employing consultants with whom they felt they could work well over the longer term, building knowledge about ways of working, and developing trust.

The four clients giving their opinions in answer to questions from the audience: Alan Colville, product manager at Telewest; David Followell, usability manager for the Nationwide Building Society; Juliet Blackburn, head of digital media at AAR Group and Sarah Herman, e-communications specialist for the Central Office of Information represented a wide variety of approaches and organisations. The Nationwide is owned by its members, the COI is public sector. AAR acts as an intermediary bringing companies and agencies together, while Telewest brought a company perspective. (The picture shows Herman, Mark Hicks of Sapient who was chairing the panel, Blackburn and Colville from left to right.)

Nonetheless, despite individual differences in set-up, priorities and ways of working, a common core of values quickly emerged about choosing and keeping external relationships with usability professionals.

'People are buying people supported by the organisation's philosophy,' said Blackburn. 'Casting is important, as is attention to detail. You don't want salespeople at the [pitching] meeting. The moment the client walks through the door the chemistry starts...'

And Colville added that Telewest will informally visit potential agencies to see how they operate in judging to whom to give a contract.

'We have three organisations we use: why change? It's a risk to move. And they have become educated in financial services,' said Followell.

Mistakes that consultants make included ignoring many aspects of user-centred design.

'We are a large company with a detailed development process and usability companies need to come in and work round it. That doesn't always happen. It's hard because usability companies are expected to be good, to know their audience,' said Colville.

Harman said that reports came back from companies so high level as to be platitudinous and so low level as to be too specific in their recommendations. Reports needed to vary to meet the client organisation's needs, said the participants: a presentation summary for the senior management, a detailed account for the developing team, and bad news presented as gently as possible. One person talked in horror of a research feedback meeting that lasted two hours.

When asked about return on investment (ROI) arguments for using usability services, panellists were cautious. Colville commented that setting up a ROI argument could leave usability as the fall-guy when targets were not met. His company favoured measuring customer satisfaction. Followell said that his team had recently introduced a process of asking their internal clients to estimate the value that usability had added – the merit of this approach was still being evaluated, but clients were 'putting bigger figures on it than we would dare'.

The four agreed that at the moment fees were falling, but none identified cost only as the determining factor in recruiting usability support. Expertise needed to be evident but not to dominate over a responsive and flexible approach.

As well as running this panel, the UK UPA is also working to produce a guide for clients, supporting them in deciding how to choose usability professionals to work with.

Poor Shopping Basket Usability will hinder Christmas Rush
Source: UN, 20 November 2008
 
A new study from eDigitalResearch identifies customer service and online shopping basket usability as the two key areas where online retailers need to improve.

Future Phones to Read Your Voice, Gestures
Source: Wired, 19 November 2008
 
Five years from now, it is likely that the mobile phone you will be holding will be a smooth, sleek brick — a piece of metal and plastic with a few grooves in it and little more.

Why Digital Research is important in tough Financial Times
Source: Financial Times, 18 November 2008
 
With the banking sector moving towards consolidation, it is crucial that customers are understood, reacted to and rewarded for their loyalty.

Get Ready for 'Ergobamanomics'
Source: AssemblyBlog via ergonomics in the news , 17 November 2008
 
Is President Elect, Barack Obama, a secret ergonomics and usability enthusiast?

The Most Dreaded Keyword Phrase
Source: SearchEngineLand, 15 November 2008
 
In website usability, one of the hardest obstacles to overcome is the mentality of “This is what I would do.”

User Experience Standards Missing from Web 2.0 Designs
Source: UN, 14 November 2008
 
Usability professionals should be more involved with the development of Web 2.0 tools.

New technology showcased at World Usability Day
Source: User Vision, 13 November 2008
 
Today is World Usability Day!

Review: 16 User Interface Prototyping Tools
Source: Dexo Design, 12 November 2008
 
People constantly ask me what the best prototyping or mockup tool is, so I decided to do a review of all the tools I’m aware of.

Radio 4's PM show announces Winner of 'Show Us a Better Way'
Source: BBC, 11 November 2008
 
Ever been frustrated that you can't find out something that ought to be easy to find? Ever been baffled by league tables or 'performance indicators'?

Cisco Systems extends Product Usability Research
Source: Catalyst Resources, 10 November 2008
 
Cisco is conducting extensive usability research with Catalyst Resources, into complex new technologies.