Media: New Thinking challenges Usability

"Usability and Listening to Customers have Limits", Gerry McGovern tells us. But has he linked these concepts too closely to leave himself with a point?

'Listening to customers and making sure your website is usable are important to website success. It is much more important, however, to have a website that delivers real value both to the organization and the reader.'

So far, we're still with you, Gerry.

'Going for value can sometimes mean going against customer feedback and usability best practice.'

Depends what you mean by 'value'... this is beginning to sound dubious. Should value and usability be opposed like this? Usability is just the analytic part of design that considers users' needs.

'When asked, Amazon.com customers seemingly didn't want one-click ordering. Jeff Bezos, founder of Amazon.com, felt otherwise. From his experience, he knew that people hated purchase processes. I read about this a couple of years ago and it really made me think. Here was someone who did not listen to his customers wishes, gave them something which they said they didn't want, which after a while they really got to like.'

Yes, we all know that customers don't know what they like till they're given it. That's why we have usability as well as market research. I thought Gerry was up to speed with this distinction. Perhaps not...

The rest of this less-than-usually-well-thought-out column goes on to criticise Nielsen obliquely for using cost savings rather than effectiveness as a value judgement in praising an intranet. As if the usability community still valued Nielsen as it used to...

And McGovern concludes: 'Usability sometimes misses the point. If you're trying to sell me red shoes, I don't care how user-friendly your website is, I'm just not interested in buying. If you're charging me 30 percent more than your competitor, all your fancy usability is pretty much irrelevant. If I think this product is cool and I must have it, I will gladly suffer an unusually designed website just to get my hands on it.'

Hmm, I don't think 'unusual design' is the problem, is it?

All these months I've been covering the McGovern column because he usually takes an interesting perspective on design. It's sad to have to take issue with his ideas. Usability... fancy? Perhaps, like Nielsen, other people can have a column so long that providing content gets gruelling and standards slip.

Associated Link: New Thinking: Usability and Listening to Customers have Limits

User Interviews - Analysis Simplified
Source: Webcredible, 6 January 2009
 
You’ve conducted your user interviews, but now you need to make sense of all that information you’ve gathered.

Why Products Fail
Source: ComputerWorld, 5 January 2009
 
Most gadget and software makers don't understand what users want most: control.

How to Design Websites for Mobile Phones
Source: stemkoski.com, 3 January 2009
 
Tips from Ryan Stemkoski's web design blog.

Pioneer of Cyberspace honoured
Source: BBC, 2 January 2009
 
A professor who invented a forerunner of the world wide web has been made a dame in the New Year Honours.

2008 in Review: Developments that rocked the world of User Experience
Source: Catalyst Resources, 1 January 2009
 
A look back at 2008 highlights some of the key developments that rocked the world of user experience.

2008: The Year Online
Source: MIT Technology Review, 31 December 2008
 
The business of social networking, cloud computing, and a flaw in the fabric of the Internet top the most notable stories of 2008.

Shoveling through the Spamalanche
Source: UN, 30 December 2008
 
A ‘Spamalanche’ of 3,000 emails will be waiting in your inbox by the time you get back to work. What can you do besides 'delete all'?

New guidelines boost Web Access
Source: BBC, 29 December 2008
 
The World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) has announced a new standard to make sites more accessible to older and disabled people.

Measuring Emotional Engagement
Source: UN, 27 December 2008
 
New applications of electroencephalography (EEG) provide the means to gather detailed information on a user’s emotional relationship with a brand or service.

UXalliance thrives on Research strengths
Source: UN, 24 December 2008
 
The UXalliance provides clients with access to over 220 user experience professionals and 40 test labs worldwide.