Comment: Showing Web Accessibility Statements the Door

Web accessibility is still in its infancy where many attempts are being made to make the web a more accessible place. I believe accessibility statements have good intentions, however as no official guidelines exists everyone has their own interpretation to what they should be. This has led to questions being raised at how effective they really are.

Now, you may think it would be easy to do a search and find the answer to this, however, its not so simple. Have you tried searching on accessibility statement lately? I got over 12M results!

So I decided to take another approach, speaking to real people and through communications on the web. The most popular response I got from the online community was that the issue is covered in PAS 78. However, web accessibility statements have been around alot longer than PAS 78, so that did not add up.

Fear of prosecution
The use of web accessibility statements seems to be linked to the Code of Practice from the DDA. It appears that the fear of being sued over inaccessible websites led to the mass introduction of accessibility statements. This made it appear that people were making an effort to make accessible sites.

Word gets around easily on the web and this resulted in accessibility statements being implemented on many sites (probably around 12 million), usually copied and pasted from on site to another (as no official guidelines existed). The excuse was that they would help users, but time has proven that the actual practice of implementing accessibility statements has not gone according to plan, they are usually:
* Too long
* Technically orientated
* Focused on displaying of adherence to standards

This means they have forgotten about their target audience how would the above benefit a disabled user who just wants to get on with things?

PAS 78
The PAS 78 states that accessibility statements should be used as contact place and for stating accessibility features such as access keys. I say there is no point.
* Most websites have a contact page anyways, why duplicate things?
* There is trend for not implementing access keys as they are believed to not be much use in practice.
* What other features are there to most websites? Increase font size? Tab order? Are these features or just common sense practice? Why state the obvious?

Afterall, if there are a stairs in a building, you wouldn't provide a statement which tells someone how to climb them. (Right leg up, left leg up!)

People keep saying we need it
Most websites are pretty straight forward.
* Do we need to state that standards and tests have passed?
* Do we need to educate a user on how to use a website?

We need to remember that the web is a different and a unique place. Once software is customised to your own needs, a user uses the same actions to perform similar tasks for any website. For example, if you use CTRL + to increase font size for one website, it will be the same for the next website you go to unless you change software/browser purposely. Surely we cannot be responsible for educating each user?

The trend for accessibility professionals
This has contributed another factor. It appears that accessibility is the trend. It's a bit like the agile development movement. Everyone is agile now, people won't hire you unless you state you are agile. It doesn't matter if you are not, it's a badge that people will believe.

So now we have accessible developers, accessible designers, accessibility and usability professionals. Perhaps if I gave myself accessibility software tester aS a title, the world would see me in a different light.

Has the concept of web accessibility been taken too far?

The solution?
I do agree, for more complex and interactive sites, there may be a requirement to offer assistance, but why not have it in a help area which addresses multiple issues. You could call it 'help', 'using this site' or 'about': it would be a central area of help and still be easy to find and of use to everyone who is interested.

Campaign against accessibility statements
A Google search returned over 12M results for accessibility statement. I am campaigning to get this number down by half. Is it possible? Is it daft? Who knows, but I believe that the web will be a more accessible place once we stop bragging about our accessibility greatness.

Rosie Sherry
DrivenQA

Associated Link: DrivenQA

Poor Shopping Basket Usability will hinder Christmas Rush
Source: UN, 20 November 2008
 
A new study from eDigitalResearch identifies customer service and online shopping basket usability as the two key areas where online retailers need to improve.

Future Phones to Read Your Voice, Gestures
Source: Wired, 19 November 2008
 
Five years from now, it is likely that the mobile phone you will be holding will be a smooth, sleek brick — a piece of metal and plastic with a few grooves in it and little more.

Why Digital Research is important in tough Financial Times
Source: Financial Times, 18 November 2008
 
With the banking sector moving towards consolidation, it is crucial that customers are understood, reacted to and rewarded for their loyalty.

Get Ready for 'Ergobamanomics'
Source: AssemblyBlog via ergonomics in the news , 17 November 2008
 
Is President Elect, Barack Obama, a secret ergonomics and usability enthusiast?

The Most Dreaded Keyword Phrase
Source: SearchEngineLand, 15 November 2008
 
In website usability, one of the hardest obstacles to overcome is the mentality of “This is what I would do.”

User Experience Standards Missing from Web 2.0 Designs
Source: UN, 14 November 2008
 
Usability professionals should be more involved with the development of Web 2.0 tools.

New technology showcased at World Usability Day
Source: User Vision, 13 November 2008
 
Today is World Usability Day!

Review: 16 User Interface Prototyping Tools
Source: Dexo Design, 12 November 2008
 
People constantly ask me what the best prototyping or mockup tool is, so I decided to do a review of all the tools I’m aware of.

Radio 4's PM show announces Winner of 'Show Us a Better Way'
Source: BBC, 11 November 2008
 
Ever been frustrated that you can't find out something that ought to be easy to find? Ever been baffled by league tables or 'performance indicators'?

Cisco Systems extends Product Usability Research
Source: Catalyst Resources, 10 November 2008
 
Cisco is conducting extensive usability research with Catalyst Resources, into complex new technologies.