Google's new 'Website Optimizer': what does it mean for User-Centred Design?

When Google releases a product it can be cataclysmic for the companies that inhabit that area. Google Website Optimizer, a User-Centred Design tool, has just been released. Should we all be looking for a new job?

Google Website Optimizer (GWO) is free, it's easy to use, and unlike conventional user testing, you don't need a research lab nor pay for participant recruitment since you tap into your existing website traffic.

This is how it works - GWO allows you to evolve your site by monitoring live user behaviour. You give it a number of different page elements and it alternates between combinations of them on your site. It then calculates the conversion rates with the live data and gives you a report showing which combinations are the most successful. It's like natural selection - the good combinations win, the bad ones die, and you sit back and watch it all happen. It's frightening how quick and cheap it is to run these tests.

But here's the weakness: GWO only records behavioural information – it doesn't record intentions. So it can show you which design combinations work well, but it can't tell you why. This is where research methods that use good old fashioned human contact come in, such as user testing, contextual interviews and ethnography. As well as observing behaviour, you talk to your user about their needs, goals and expectations. You don't just look at the computer screen, you look into their eyes, and you listen to what they have to say. This gives you a rich understanding of what makes them tick, helping you think beyond your current designs.

Put another way, GWO supports convergent creativity – it allows you to hone in and optimize your designs. While this is obviously important, it misses out on the other side of things – divergent creativity – which involves coming up with radically new ideas that inherit almost nothing from your prior thinking. The old saying "garbage in, garbage out" holds true for GWO - it's only going to give you good results if you put good stuff in. With human contact research, you can turn up with nothing but a blank notepad and an open mind, and you can walk away brimming with new ideas.

So don't worry about GWO putting you out of a job - it's not going to happen. It's useful, it's perfect for convergent design on live sites, but ultimately it's just another tool for your toolbox.


Harry Brignull is a User-Experience Consultant at Flow Interactive. If you have any comments or suggestions about this article then please contact harry@flow-interactive.com

Associated Link: Google Website Optimizer

'Internet addiction' linked to Depression
Source: BBC, 9 February 2010
 
There is a strong link between heavy internet use and depression, UK psychologists have said.

Could *You* be more Usable?
Source: UN, 8 February 2010
 
Bet you could.

Stowe Boyd on 'Steampunk' thinking about the Future of Computing
Source: Stowe Boyd's blog via Experientia, 6 February 2010
 
Are established metaphors of user experience holding us back from new ways of structuring our interaction through computers?

Nokia's User Experience Programme
Source: UN, 5 February 2010
 
Nokia has put together a rich and informative website covering the key elements of user experience.

Interfaces magazine: latest issue available now
Source: HCI News Service, 4 February 2010
 
The latest issue of Interfaces is now available in pdf format, free from the Interaction Website.

A Lighter Brigade of Chargers
Source: UN, 3 February 2010
 
Lots of gadgets, one charger. At last.

Mobile Touch Screens could soon Feel the Pressure
Source: MIT Technology Review, 2 February 2010
 
A quantum switch could add pressure sensing to mobile screens.

Usability, Usability, Usability: why the iPad will Succeed
Source: Econsultancy, 1 February 2010
 
The tech critics love it, hate it, love it again, shrug it off. What do usability experts say?

British Airways - at last some good news
Source: Loop11, 30 January 2010
 
In a recent website usability study for the world's leading airlines, the British Airways website proved to be the most user friendly, with Malaysia Airlines and Virgin Atlantic having the lowest user experience rating.

Computation of Emotions in Man and Machine
Source: Royal Society, 29 January 2010
 
Advances in computer technology now allow machines to recognise and express emotions, paving the way for improved human-computer and human-human communications.